Shares of NYCB fall more than 20% after bank discloses ‘internal controls’ issue, CEO change

US Markets
Friday, March 1st, 2024 4:23 pm EDT

Key Points

  • Leadership Change and Internal Control Issues: New York Community Bancorp’s shares plummeted by over 26% following the announcement of a leadership transition, with Alessandro DiNello assuming the roles of president and CEO. This change coincided with disclosures of material weaknesses in internal controls, particularly related to internal loan review, attributed to ineffective oversight, risk assessment, and monitoring activities.
  • Financial Performance and Market Reaction: NYCB’s stock experienced a sharp decline in after-hours trading, reflecting investor concerns over the bank’s internal control issues and leadership changes. The bank also amended its fourth-quarter results to include a disclosure about its internal risk management, adding to the negative sentiment in the market.
  • Market Challenges and Regulatory Environment: NYCB’s struggles are indicative of broader challenges faced by regional banks, particularly concerning commercial real estate exposure. The disclosure of larger-than-expected charges against potential loan losses in January further exacerbated concerns about the health of the commercial real estate market. This has led to a broader market downturn, with fears about the stability of regional banks and the impact of loan losses on their balance sheets, as evidenced by several regional bank failures in 2023. NYCB’s acquisition of Signature, a failed bank, underscores the complexities and risks within the banking sector amidst changing market conditions and regulatory scrutiny.

New York Community Bancorp experienced a significant decline of over 26% in its shares following the announcement of a leadership transition and revelations regarding internal control issues. The regional lender disclosed that Alessandro DiNello, its executive chairman, would immediately assume the roles of president and CEO. This move comes amidst mounting concerns about the bank’s exposure to commercial real estate, contributing to pressure on NYCB in recent months. The announcement, made after market close on Thursday, also included an amendment to its fourth-quarter results, highlighting internal risk management concerns. Management identified material weaknesses in internal controls related to internal loan review, citing ineffective oversight, risk assessment, and monitoring activities. DiNello, previously CEO of Flagstar Bank, acquired by NYCB in 2022, took on the executive chairman role at NYCB in February, shortly after a credit rating downgrade to junk status by Moody’s Investors Service. Despite recent challenges, DiNello expressed confidence in the bank’s direction and its ability to serve customers, employees, and shareholders. Another leadership change saw Marshall Lux elevated to presiding director of the NYCB board, succeeding Hanif Dahya. Lux, formerly global chief risk officer for Chase Consumer Bank at JP Morgan, brings a wealth of experience to the role. NYCB’s shares have plummeted by 53% year-to-date, prompted by its disclosure in January of a larger-than-expected charge against potential loan losses. Concerns about loan losses have reignited fears about the commercial real estate market and the stability of regional banks, with several failing in 2023 due to uncertainties about the value of debt on their balance sheets. NYCB itself acquired one of these failed banks, Signature, in March of the previous year.

For the full original article on CNBC, please click here: https://www.cnbc.com/2024/02/29/shares-of-nycb-fall-more-than-10percent-after-bank-discloses-internal-controls-issue-ceo-change.html